Compact Elongated Toilet vs. Round Toilet: Which Is Better?
When it comes to designing or renovating your bathroom, one of the most important decisions you’ll need to make is choosing the right toilet. With so many options available, it can be difficult to determine which model is best suited to your needs.
Two of the most popular toilet styles are the compact elongated toilet and the round toilet. While both serve the same purpose, they differ in design, comfort, space-saving features, and performance.
In this article, we’ll compare the advantages and disadvantages of compact elongated toilets versus round toilets, exploring factors like comfort, space requirements, ease of use, and overall aesthetics. By the end, you’ll have a clearer idea of which toilet style works best for your bathroom layout and preferences.
What is a Compact Elongated Toilet?
A compact elongated toilet combines the benefits of an elongated toilet bowl with a space-saving design. Elongated toilets are known for their extended bowl, which provides more seating comfort and improved ergonomics.
However, traditional elongated toilets can sometimes take up more space in smaller bathrooms. A compact elongated toilet offers a solution by shortening the length of the toilet bowl while maintaining the comfort of an elongated shape.
For those who want the comfort of an elongated toilet but have limited space, a one-piece compact elongated toilet is a popular choice. These models are designed as a single, seamless unit, often making cleaning easier and more efficient.
What is a Round Toilet?
A round toilet, also known as a round-front toilet, is a more traditional design where the toilet bowl has a circular shape, making it more compact than the elongated version.
Round toilets have been around for a long time and are known for their space-saving capabilities. These toilets are generally shorter in length, which allows them to fit well in smaller bathrooms or bathrooms with limited space.
Round toilets typically offer a more economical option, both in terms of cost and space requirements. For those with a small bathroom, the round toilet can be a great choice without sacrificing functionality.
Key Differences Between Compact Elongated Toilets and Round Toilets
Let’s explore the key differences between compact elongated toilets and round toilets to help you decide which option is the best fit for your bathroom.
1. Comfort and Ergonomics
Compact Elongated Toilet:
One of the main advantages of a compact elongated toilet is the added comfort. The elongated shape provides a more spacious seating area compared to the round design. This added length typically offers more room for your legs and allows for a more comfortable sitting position.
The compact elongated toilet seat is often preferred by individuals looking for a more ergonomic and comfortable bathroom experience. This makes it an excellent choice for households with multiple users, as it caters to a broader range of body types and offers better overall support.
Round Toilet:
The round toilet generally has a smaller bowl, which may be less comfortable for some users, especially for those who are taller or larger. The compact size of the round toilet makes it less spacious, which can lead to a cramped experience.
However, it might be more comfortable for children or smaller users who find the compact design more manageable. If comfort isn’t a top priority, and you’re simply looking for a functional toilet, the round option can still meet your needs.
2. Space Efficiency
Compact Elongated Toilet:
While a compact elongated toilet provides a higher level of comfort, it still manages to save space compared to standard elongated toilets. By shortening the length of the toilet bowl, these models allow you to get the best of both worlds: comfort and space efficiency.
One-piece compact elongated toilets are especially beneficial for smaller bathrooms because their design eliminates the need for two separate pieces (the tank and the bowl) and is typically easier to clean.
Round Toilet:
When it comes to space-saving, round toilets have a clear advantage. Their shorter design allows them to fit comfortably in tight spaces, making them ideal for smaller bathrooms or powder rooms.
If you’re working with a bathroom that has limited square footage, such as a half-bath or a cramped guest bathroom, a round toilet is a great option. However, while it saves space, it might not offer the same level of comfort that an elongated design provides.
3. Aesthetics and Design
Compact Elongated Toilet:
A compact elongated toilet often has a more modern and sophisticated appearance. The smooth, oval bowl gives it an elegant, contemporary look that works well in a wide range of bathroom styles, from minimalist to luxurious.
Additionally, one-piece compact elongated toilets are often preferred for their seamless design, making them easier to clean and giving the bathroom a sleek, integrated look. These toilets are ideal for people looking to add a touch of luxury and elegance to their space.
Round Toilet:
The round toilet has a more traditional, classic design that may not appeal to everyone, especially those looking for a more contemporary look. However, round toilets are still highly functional and are a great fit for more utilitarian or budget-friendly bathrooms.
The compact nature of the round toilet also makes it easier to place in smaller or more cramped spaces without feeling crowded, which might suit certain bathroom designs better.
4. Installation and Cost
Compact Elongated Toilet:
Compact elongated toilets typically cost more than round toilets due to their added comfort and space-saving features. While they offer a more comfortable seating experience, they may also come with a higher price tag, particularly if you opt for advanced features like one-piece compact elongated toilets, which combine the tank and bowl in one unit.
Installation for a one-piece compact elongated toilet might also be slightly more complicated and may require professional installation, especially if it’s a heavier model.
Round Toilet:
Round toilets are often the more budget-friendly option. Because of their simpler design and smaller size, they generally cost less to purchase and install.
For homeowners on a tight budget or those who need a toilet for a smaller bathroom without compromising on functionality, the round toilet is a more affordable option. Installation is also relatively straightforward for round toilets, making them a convenient choice for DIY projects.
5. Cleaning and Maintenance
Compact Elongated Toilet:
Compact elongated toilets are generally easier to clean than traditional two-piece models because the bowl and tank are integrated into one seamless unit. This means there are fewer crevices where dirt and grime can accumulate.
Additionally, the elongated shape may make it easier to clean thoroughly, as it offers more surface area to work with.
Round Toilet:
Cleaning a round toilet is typically simple due to its compact size, but the design can sometimes lead to a less efficient clean, especially in the areas around the rim and base. The traditional two-piece design may also leave more seams where cleaning may be less effective.
However, round toilets are still easy to maintain in comparison to some larger, bulkier toilet models.
Which Toilet is Right for You?
Ultimately, the decision between a compact elongated toilet and a round toilet depends on your specific needs and bathroom layout. Let’s recap the key factors to consider:
- Space Availability: If you have a small bathroom or powder room, a round toilet is the best space-saving option. It will fit comfortably in tight spaces while offering the functionality you need.
- Comfort: If comfort is your priority, a compact elongated toilet will be your best bet. The elongated bowl provides more space and comfort, especially for adults or larger users. A compact elongated toilet seat is also more ergonomic, making it a better choice for households with multiple users.
- Design and Aesthetics: If you’re looking for a modern, sleek look, a one-piece compact elongated toilet will add a touch of elegance to your bathroom. Its seamless design and higher-end features make it a great choice for contemporary bathroom styles.
- Budget: If you’re working within a tight budget, a round toilet offers an affordable, functional solution. It’s easy to install, simple to maintain, and fits well in smaller bathrooms.
- Maintenance and Durability: A compact elongated toilet tends to be easier to clean, especially in one-piece designs. The simpler design of the round toilet may not offer the same level of ease, but it remains a low-maintenance option.
Conclusion
Both compact elongated toilets and round toilets offer distinct advantages depending on your bathroom’s size, your comfort needs, and your budget. If you’re looking for maximum comfort, space efficiency, and modern design, a compact elongated toilet might be your best choice.
On the other hand, if space is tight and you need a cost-effective solution, a round toilet can still provide the functionality you need without compromising on performance.
For those seeking elongated toilet bowls that offer enhanced comfort and design, it’s worth exploring options like the elongated toilet bowls, which can provide a more comfortable experience without taking up too much space.
