Deck Contractor vs. DIY: Why Hiring a Pro Saves You Time and Money

Building a new deck is one of the best ways to enhance your outdoor living space and increase your home's value, but deciding how to build it can be a challenge in itself. Should you tackle it as a do-it-yourself project or bring in a professional deck contractor?

While the DIY route may seem like the cheaper option at first glance, the reality is that hiring a licensed deck contractor can save you both time and money in the long run. Let's break down the real differences when it comes to cost, time, and quality.

1. Cost: Upfront Savings vs. Long-Term Value

a) DIY Decking:

Doing it yourself can appear to save money because you’re not paying for labor. You might think, “I’ll just watch a few YouTube videos and knock it out in a few weekends.” But the materials still cost money, and if you don’t already own tools like a miter saw, drill, post hole digger, or level, the expenses can add up fast.

Also, mistakes cost money. Mis-measured cuts, uneven framing, or improperly installed footings can lead to wasted materials or even structural problems that require expensive fixes.

b) Hiring a Deck Contractor:

While hiring a deck contractor involves labor costs, it also means your project is handled efficiently and correctly the first time. Contractors often have access to bulk discounts on high-quality materials and already own the specialized tools needed for the job.

c) The Bottom Line on Cost:

DIY may save you 15–30% in labor upfront, but unexpected mistakes, rework, and tool rentals can quickly close that gap. A deck contractor ensures the job is done right and up to code, saving you from expensive repairs later on.

2. Time: Your Free Weekends vs. a Contractor’s Full-Time Focus

a) DIY Decking:

If you’re juggling a full-time job, family life, and weekend obligations, building a deck can easily stretch into a months-long project. Between learning building techniques, gathering materials, and fixing inevitable mistakes, your “weekend project” could take 6–12 weeks or more.

b) Hiring a Deck Contractor:

A professional deck contractor works full time, often with a crew, and knows exactly how to manage a project from design to completion. They can typically build a standard deck in 1–2 weeks. Plus, they handle permitting, inspections, and scheduling—all of which can eat up your time if you go the DIY route.

c) The Bottom Line on Time:

DIY decks cost more in terms of your personal time. Hiring a contractor gives you back your weekends and gets you enjoying your new deck much faster.

3. Quality: Learning on the Fly vs. Expert Craftsmanship

a) DIY Decking:

Unless you're experienced in construction, you’ll face a steep learning curve. Even minor errors in spacing, fastener placement, or support can affect the safety and longevity of your deck. And if you’re not familiar with your local building codes, you could end up with a deck that doesn’t pass inspection, forcing you to start over.

b) Hiring a Deck Contractor:

An experienced deck contractor brings years of knowledge and hands-on experience to your project. They understand how to build structurally sound decks that comply with local building codes, can handle tricky terrain or custom features, and often offer warranties on both materials and labor.

c) The Bottom Line on Quality:

DIY decks may work, but they often show signs of amateur construction—uneven boards, shaky railings, or mismatched fasteners. A contractor delivers professional results that not only look great but last longer and increase your home’s value.

Bonus: Permits, Codes, and Liability

Many cities and counties require permits for deck construction. A deck contractor Idaho Falls knows exactly what paperwork is needed and how to pass inspections. If you're building without a permit or building incorrectly, you could face fines, delays, or even be forced to tear the structure down.

Also, if someone gets injured on a deck you built incorrectly, you could be held liable. Contractors carry insurance that protects both you and them in case of accidents.

Final Verdict: Is DIY Ever Worth It?

If you have extensive building experience, all the right tools, and plenty of time on your hands, a DIY deck may be a fulfilling personal project. But for most homeowners, the risks and hidden costs often outweigh the initial savings.

Hiring a professional deck contractor not only delivers better results but also offers peace of mind that your investment is safe, compliant, and built to last.